Testimonials

Mary Kate H.

Casey is the best of the best. Moving across the country can be a challenging endeavor, especially when searching for a new home in the highly competitive real estate market. However, our experience with Casey has made our transition to Milton fun! From the moment we connected with Casey, her professionalism and genuine dedication to helping us find our dream home were evident. She guided us through every step of the process, providing expert advice and invaluable insights about the local market. Her extensive knowledge of North Atlanta and Milton was truly impressive. One aspect that truly sets Casey apart is her incredible relationships with other realtors in the area. In this fiercely competitive market, her connections and rapport with other agents proved to be instrumental in securing our dream home. We found ourselves in a multi-offer situation, which could have been overwhelming, …

Casey is the best of the best. Moving across the country can be a challenging endeavor, especially when searching for a new home in the highly competitive real estate market. However, our experience with Casey has made our transition to Milton fun! From the moment we connected with Casey, her professionalism and genuine dedication to helping us find our dream home were evident. She guided us through every step of the process, providing expert advice and invaluable insights about the local market. Her extensive knowledge of North Atlanta and Milton was truly impressive. One aspect that truly sets Casey apart is her incredible relationships with other realtors in the area. In this fiercely competitive market, her connections and rapport with other agents proved to be instrumental in securing our dream home. We found ourselves in a multi-offer situation, which could have been overwhelming, but Casey's strategic negotiations and excellent communication skills ensured we stood out among the other buyers. I can't say enough good things about Casey. Trust that you will be in the best hands when working with her.

Jenn & Luke M.

We started working with Casey about 9 months ago to begin the search in Milton for a home with more space. We weren’t in a hurry to find a new home because we loved our current home in Brookhaven so much. We have very specific tastes we know what we like and what we don’t and what we’re willing to invest in. Casey took time to really understand what we were looking for - she never made us feel pressure to move into a house we weren’t sure about- she always had our best interest at heart. We even walked away from a house we had gone under contract for, but Casey didn’t miss a beat - she simply said “It’s not the one and we’ll keep looking”. She eventually found the perfect home for us off the market - we didn’t have to compete with one buyer for this home. We listed our Brookhaven home with her as well- receiving multiple offers and closing 10% over asking. She has exceeded our expectatio…

We started working with Casey about 9 months ago to begin the search in Milton for a home with more space. We weren’t in a hurry to find a new home because we loved our current home in Brookhaven so much. We have very specific tastes we know what we like and what we don’t and what we’re willing to invest in. Casey took time to really understand what we were looking for - she never made us feel pressure to move into a house we weren’t sure about- she always had our best interest at heart. We even walked away from a house we had gone under contract for, but Casey didn’t miss a beat - she simply said “It’s not the one and we’ll keep looking”. She eventually found the perfect home for us off the market - we didn’t have to compete with one buyer for this home. We listed our Brookhaven home with her as well- receiving multiple offers and closing 10% over asking. She has exceeded our expectations in every way. I would recommend her a million times over to anyone looking for their next home. Thank you Casey for everything!

Erica S.

Casey is the best agent we have ever worked with, hands down. I've never met an agent with as much intentionality as Casey (and her team). Being a former management consultant allowed Casey to bring an entirely heightened skillset to both the sale and purchase of our homes- above and beyond what you expect of your typical agent. Not only did she sell our home in one weekend, but she got us our dream home less than 24 hours after it was on the market. She took the time to show us homes we wanted to see, responded to our questions immediately, aggressively negotiated on our behalf, and made us feel more like friends every time we interacted. Casey was so knowledgeable about the luxury housing market and continued to impress us throughout the process. We are sad the entire process is over that’s how great it was to work with her! Cannot wait to work with her again on our future homes!

Anna Z.

After purchasing a new home, our previous home sat on the market for two months with another agent with no offers. As soon as the holiday season was over we knew we had to do something different. We reached out to Casey, and from the beginning, we could tell we were in good hands and made the best decision. She came in with a plan and made us feel confident in selling our home. Her knowledge and expertise made the entire process much less stressful and she was able to meet a timeline we thought wouldn’t even be possible. Being in the month of January made us nervous, but Casey blew our expectations and had our home sold in one weekend with multiple offers over the listing price. It was a seamless, smooth process from start to finish, and couldn’t imagine working with anyone else. We wouldn’t hesitate to recommend her to anyone! Thank you, Casey!

Work With Casey

Casey Rutherford is relationship driven and results oriented. Connecting with other top real estate agents is a priority for her, as she uses her professional network to win deals, stay informed of off market and coming soon properties, and to proactively market homes for sale. Her keen eye for design allows her to help buyers envision what a home could like and gives sellers the tools they need to prepare their home for market. Your largest investment is Casey’s largest priority.

Follow Me on Instagram